Crows & Ravens: The consciousness of corvids (#330)

As children, many of us watched a crow tilt its head or a raven glide overhead and wondered: What’s going on inside their minds?

For much of scientific history, even asking that question was taboo. To speak of an animal’s consciousness was to risk ridicule. But the landscape has changed, thanks in large part to pioneering researchers who insisted that the study of animal minds belongs in the scientific arena.

Today, a growing body of research has revealed something extraordinary:

The corvid family - ravens, crows, jays, and magpies - not only challenge our assumptions about intelligence, but force us to reconsider the very nature of consciousness.

A New View of Avian Minds

Long dismissed as mere mimics or instinct-driven foragers, corvids have astonished scientists with their cognitive prowess. They solve puzzles, use tools, deceive rivals, and recognize individual human faces. Their abilities have earned them the nickname feathered apes, but the truth may be more radical:

These birds may not just be smart - they may be conscious.

In a recent cross-disciplinary study, philosophers and scientists examined five dimensions of corvid experience: behavior, cognition, neurobiology, emotion, and self-awareness. Their findings suggest that corvids may possess a subjective inner life. A life shaped by memory, perception, emotion, and social connection.

Memory Like No Other

Take food caching, for example.

Corvids don’t just hide food, they remember where they put it, what it was, and how long ago they stored it.

This level of episodic memory is rare in the animal kingdom. Some corvids can cache and accurately recall over a thousand food items in a single month. That’s a memory feat that would leave any human struggling.

They also use memory in remarkably flexible ways. Jays, for instance, have been observed planning for the future - not just storing food, but storing tools, like spoons or sticks, for a task they anticipate needing to solve later. This isn’t instinct, it’s foresight. It implies a continuity of self across time.

And social memory is just as sophisticated. Male jays have been seen observing what foods females prefer during feeding, then later bringing those foods as a courtship offering, suggesting not only memory, but empathy and strategic social behavior.

Emotional Intelligence

Corvids don’t just think, they feel. They experience mood states that influence their decisions. Like humans, they show cognitive biases: pessimism after witnessing distress in others, joy after successful tool use, and neophobia (a wariness of novelty) that tempers their willingness to explore unfamiliar objects or people. Even the offer of a treat won’t lure a wild crow near a stranger. But a familiar human is welcomed with confidence.

Their emotional complexity challenges the long-held belief that rich inner lives are exclusive to mammals. And it reminds us that birds, too, may carry memories of both joy and pain, possibly for a long time.

A Mind with Two Hemispheres and One Experience

The structure of the corvid brain is fascinating in itself. Unlike mammals, birds lack a corpus callosum, the thick bundle of nerves that connects the two brain hemispheres. In mammals, this structure helps integrate the left and right sides of our minds into a single stream of consciousness.

Corvids, however, show remarkable hemispheric specialization, sometimes using one eye for close examination and the other for scanning threats. Does this imply a split consciousness or a different kind of unity?

Some researchers liken this to split-brain human patients - people whose corpus callosum has been severed to treat epilepsy. When shown different images in each visual field, these individuals can draw one and describe the other, suggesting two centers of awareness. Corvids may have something similar: not two selves, but a nonlinear, multi-threaded consciousness that processes the world from multiple, concurrent perspectives.

Self-Awareness and Theory of Mind

Corvids pass modified versions of the mirror test, suggesting a form of self-recognition. But even more compelling is their theory of mind - the ability to infer what others know, want, or intend. A raven observed hiding food will return to move the stash only if it has stolen from others in the past, implying an understanding of deception based on personal experience.

This recursive thinking, where birds base behavior on what they imagine others might do, is rare and sophisticated. Even relatively solitary corvids, like ravens, exhibit highly developed social skills. Their capacity for complex interaction was once thought exclusive to highly social mammals. No longer.

Consciousness and Responsibility

All of this raises an urgent question: if corvids are conscious, what do we owe them?

Understanding what the world is like for these birds - how they perceive, remember, suffer, and enjoy - has profound implications for corvid welfare.

Their excellent memory suggests they may relive trauma long after it ends.

Their neophobia implies that change must be introduced gently.

Their social nature means that housing them alone may cause distress.

And their love of tools and exploration opens new avenues for enrichment and care.

Yet for many species, it is a lack of research, not a lack of capacity, that prevents us from understanding their experiences. The more we learn, the more it becomes clear: these birds deserve not just our fascination, but our ethical attention.

Rick’s Commentary

Crows and ravens don’t just watch us.

They study us.

They remember us.

They respond to us not as background noise in their world, but as individual agents in their social landscape.

When a crow looks at you, it’s not merely reacting.

It’s reflecting. Judging. Choosing.

We once assumed that consciousness had a narrow range. But the corvids - bright-minded and emotionally attuned - invite us to redraw those lines.

To reconsider what it means to have a mind.

To wonder, with renewed humility, what other creatures might know of joy, time, pain, and self.

In the eyes of a raven, we may find more than intelligence. We may glimpse a consciousness - different from ours, yet deeply, resonantly real.

#bunyipsbooksbeyond