In Praise of the Contrarian (2 of 2): When animals defy the norm (#319)

While contrarianism is a human concept rooted in reasoning and culture, certain animals behave in ways that resemble contrarianism: going against group norms, resisting typical roles, or challenging hierarchy.

• Elephants - The Empathic Non-Conformists

• Elephant matriarchs sometimes defy herd expectations by leading their group to unknown water sources or refusing to migrate with other herds if they sense danger.

• Their decisions can go against majority movement but often turn out to be life-saving.

• Lone Wolves - By Choice, Not by Force

• While wolves are famously pack animals, some choose to go solo, especially when leaving to find new territory or escape competition.

• Lone wolves are often pioneers, taking bold risks to find mates and establish new packs.

• African Grey Parrots - Verbal Rebels

• Known for exceptional intelligence, some African greys appear to deliberately say the opposite of what’s expected.

• They’ve been consistently documented playfully teasing or contradicting their owners.

• Octopuses - Curious, Independent Thinkers

• Octopuses often act in unpredictable ways.

• Some defy training, explore lab environments on their own terms, and even squirt water at lights or people, seeming to disobey expectations with surprising autonomy.

• Gorillas & Chimps - Social Subverters

• Primates sometimes defy dominance hierarchies.

• Young males may challenge alphas earlier than expected.

• Some females cooperate to resist aggressive males - actions that disrupt social norms for safety or fairness.

• Horses – Sensitive Objectors

• Horses labeled stubborn are often actually being sensitive and discerning.

• Some refuse to follow commands when they detect danger or discomfort, going against a rider’s cue in ways that demonstrate independent judgment.

• Lab Rats and Mice - The Surprising Outliers

• In research, there are always a few rodents that break expected behavioral patterns, choosing less rewarding paths, resisting conditioning, or showing unexpected empathy.

• They’re sometimes dubbed non-responders, but in truth, they’re the outliers who make scientists rethink assumptions.

Rick’s Commentary

While animals may not be contrarian in a philosophical sense, their behaviors often remind us that going against the grain isn’t always irrational.

It may be the most adaptive move in the long run.

#bunyipsbooksbeyond