Science and Democracy: Russell’s call for citizens who build (#368)

Every time I read Bertrand Russell, I wonder how he saw so clearly into the future. His words about science, imagination, and human nature read like a diagnosis of our current political sickness – and a prescription for healing.

Without science, there is no democracy.

Without imagination, there is no progress.

Bertrand Russell wrote this in 1926. Today, his words read like a last warning to a divided world.

In 1926, as the world rebuilt after World War 1, Bertrand Russell issued a challenge: build a society grounded in science and imagination, or watch it collapse under dogma and destruction.

Almost a century later, his challenge remains unanswered.

What if the greatest threat to democracy isn’t a political party or foreign power, but our own failure to think clearly, build wisely, and educate deeply?

 

Science, Imagination, & the Choice Between Construction & Destruction

In his 1926 book Education and the Good Life, British philosopher Bertrand Russell argued passionately for an education system that fosters not only knowledge but wisdom, imagination, and character.

Nearly a century later, his words remain strikingly relevant.

Russell saw applied science as the cornerstone of human progress. He envisioned a world where industrial advances could eliminate chronic disease, hunger, and extreme poverty.

Yet he issued a clear warning: without the humanities and the cultivation of imagination, such a world would be barren.

He wrote:

It is only through imagination that men become aware of what the world might be; without it, progress would become mechanical and trivial.

He feared that a purely mechanistic civilization would sacrifice beauty, art, and meaning at the altar of efficiency.

Science as the Key to Democracy

Russell believed that science and democracy are inseparable. Science, he argued, instills in people a mindset of cautious inquiry – a willingness to act on knowledge while accepting the possibility of error and correction. In contrast, dogma breeds rigidity, while pure skepticism breeds paralysis. The scientific temper, he said, requires believing that knowledge is attainable – with difficulty and care – and acting upon it responsibly:

Neither acquiescence in skepticism nor acquiescence in dogma is what education should produce.

Such a mindset is essential for a healthy democracy, which depends on citizens who can think critically, embrace complexity, and avoid the twin traps of unthinking certainty or cynical nihilism.

Human Nature: Construction vs. Destruction

Perhaps the most profound of Russell’s reflections concerns the dual potential in human nature.

He wrote:

In the immense majority of children, there is the raw material of a good citizen and the raw material of a criminal.

He saw our instincts as ethically neutral. Whether they are shaped towards good or evil depends on environment, education, and society.

At the heart of human motivation, Russell saw the will to power, which can manifest in both constructive and destructive ways.

Destruction is easy and often gives a quick sense of power, but it is construction that brings lasting satisfaction.

As he put it:

The first beginnings of many virtues arise out of experiencing the joys of construction.

Russell urged educators and leaders to foster the constructive impulse in young people, guiding their intelligence and imagination towards building rather than breaking.

Why Russell’s Words Matter in Today’s Political Climate

Today, as we face global challenges of climate change, inequality, and technological disruption, Russell’s insistence on integrating science, imagination, and moral education feels prescient.

His words are a reminder that progress is not just about what we build, but how and why we build it – and whether we are cultivating citizens who value construction over destruction.

Nearly a century after Bertrand Russell wrote Education and the Good Life, his insights resonate with urgency in today’s political landscape.

Dogma and Skepticism in Modern Politics

Russell warned against the dangers of both dogma and skepticism – an insight visible in today’s polarized world. On one side, rigid ideology demands absolute loyalty, leaving no room for nuance or self-correction. On the other, corrosive skepticism dismisses expertise, scientific consensus, and shared truths, undermining collective action.

Russell argued that democracy depends on a scientific temper, where citizens accept that:

Knowledge is attainable, though difficult and imperfect.

Mistakes can be corrected through care and industry.

Action is necessary, even while acknowledging the possibility of error.

In a time when conspiracy theories thrive and alternative facts undermine public trust, Russell’s call for educated, critically thinking citizens is more relevant than ever.

Russell’s reflections on human nature – that construction is more difficult but more satisfying than destruction – speak directly to the destructive tendencies in modern politics.

Inflammatory rhetoric, culture wars, and legislative sabotage often bring quick political rewards.

Building policies, coalitions, and social cohesion is harder, slower, and less glamorous.

Yet, as Russell observed, real virtue and progress come from construction.

He wrote:

The first beginnings of many virtues arise out of experiencing the joys of construction.

Leaders who choose to build – whether infrastructure, healthcare systems, or bridges between communities – demonstrate a moral courage absent in those who simply tear down.

Science, Education, and Democracy

Russell’s insistence that science is essential to democracy underscores current debates on climate change, public health, and technology regulation. Democracies falter when citizens lack the scientific literacy to evaluate policies, resist disinformation, and hold leaders accountable.

His warning against a purely utilitarian education is equally salient. An education system focused only on producing workers for the economy neglects the arts, ethics, and philosophy – the very disciplines that teach us how to use leisure and health wisely, how to imagine better futures, and how to live with meaning.

Rick’s Commentary

Russell’s vision is a reminder that politics is an extension of education.

If we want a democratic society capable of constructive action, we must educate citizens who:

Value science and critical thinking.

Resist both dogmatic certainty and nihilistic skepticism.

Choose construction over destruction, even when it is hard.

In a time of crisis and division, Russell’s words challenge us to ask:

Are we fostering a culture that builds or destroys?

Are we educating for democracy or dogma?

Postscript

Bertrand Arthur William Russell, 3rd Earl Russell (1872 - 1970) was a British philosopher, logician, mathematician, and public intellectual. He had influence on  logic, set theory, and analytic philosophy. In 1950, Russell was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in recognition of his varied and significant writings in which he championed humanitarian ideals and freedom of thought.

#bunyipsbooksbeyond