The Future of Veterinary Education: Part 7. Teaching Judgment (#665)

The Skill No One Can Fully Define

Part 7 is, in many ways, the centerpiece of this series on The Future of Veterinary Education.

The previous six essays have all been building toward this question.

If AI can retrieve knowledge, if competencies can measure skills, if examinations can assess recall, and if curricula can deliver information, then:

What is the one thing that distinguishes an exceptional veterinarian from a merely competent one?

The answer may be judgment.

Ask a group of veterinarians to describe the best clinician they have ever known.

The answers will vary.

Some will mention intelligence. Others will mention technical skill. Others will mention compassion.

But eventually someone will say:

They had excellent judgment.

Interestingly, everyone immediately understands what that means.

Yet few can define it.

Judgment may be one of the most important qualities in veterinary medicine.

It may also be one of the most difficult to teach.

Knowledge Is Not Judgment

A student can memorize every cranial nerve.

A resident can recite the differential diagnoses for seizures.

A specialist can recall the latest research paper.

None of those things guarantees good judgment.

Knowledge is essential.

But knowledge alone is insufficient.

Every veterinarian eventually encounters situations where the correct decision is not obvious.

The textbook is unclear. The evidence is incomplete. The owner has financial limitations. The patient has multiple problems. Time is short. Emotions are high. The veterinarian must decide.

That decision is judgment.

The Question Behind the Question

Clients rarely come to veterinarians seeking information alone.

Information is increasingly available everywhere.

Instead, they often seek something deeper.

Guidance. Perspective. Reassurance. Confidence.

Consider the owner who asks:

What would you do if this were your dog?

That question appears simple.

But it is actually asking:

How do you interpret all of the information?

How do you weigh the risks?

How do you balance quality of life, probability of success, cost, and uncertainty?

What matters most?

No textbook or algorithm can answer that question completely.

The veterinarian must.

The Problem with Teaching Judgment

The challenge is obvious.

Knowledge can be taught. Skills can be demonstrated. Competencies can be assessed.

Judgment is different.

Judgment develops through experience.

And experience refuses to be rushed.

Many educators have observed an interesting phenomenon.

Students often ask:

Will this be on the examination?

Experienced clinicians ask:

When would I use this in practice?

The difference is profound.

One seeks the correct answer.

The other seeks understanding.

Judgment begins when the search for answers gives way to the search for meaning.

The Neurology Lesson

Neurology provides countless examples.

Two dogs may present with seemingly identical signs. The MRI findings may be similar. The diagnoses may even be identical. Yet the recommended course of action may be very different.

Age. Breed. Temperament. Owner expectations. Financial considerations. Concurrent disease. Quality of life.

Each influences decision-making.

The challenge is not identifying the disease.

The challenge is determining what should happen next.

That is where judgment lives.

The Role of Mistakes

One uncomfortable truth about judgment is that it often develops through mistakes.

Not catastrophic mistakes. Not negligent mistakes. Human mistakes.

The cases we misinterpreted.

The diagnoses we missed.

The conversations we wish we had handled differently.

The recommendations that did not produce the expected outcome.

Many veterinarians can identify a handful of cases that shaped their entire careers.

Not because they succeeded.

But because they learned.

Judgment is frequently built from reflection upon experience.

Why Mentorship Matters

This is why mentorship remains so important.

Experienced clinicians possess something that textbooks cannot provide.

Perspective.

They have seen patterns repeat themselves.

They have witnessed successes and failures.

They understand not only what can happen but what usually happens.

Young veterinarians often seek knowledge from mentors.

What they truly receive is judgment.

A mentor shortens the distance between experience and understanding.

Not by eliminating mistakes.

But by helping others learn from them.

The Danger of Certainty

One of the paradoxes of professional development is that confidence and judgment do not always develop together.

Students often crave certainty.

New graduates often seek certainty.

Yet experienced veterinarians gradually discover that medicine contains remarkably little certainty.

Good judgment is not the ability to eliminate uncertainty.

Good judgment is the ability to function effectively despite uncertainty.

The best clinicians are rarely the most dogmatic.

The best clinicians are often the most thoughtful.

The most curious.

The most willing to say:

I don't know.

Paradoxically, humility may be one of the foundations of sound judgment.

Can Judgment Be Assessed?

This question inevitably arises.

If judgment is so important, can it be measured?

To some degree, yes.

Case discussions can reveal reasoning. Clinical evaluations can reveal decision-making.

Simulations can reveal thought processes.

But judgment remains difficult to reduce to a score.

It emerges over time.

Across multiple situations.

Through repeated observation.

This may explain why experienced faculty members can often identify outstanding future clinicians long before objective metrics do.

They are observing judgment.

Even if they cannot fully quantify it.

The Wisdom Gap

Perhaps veterinary education has become exceptionally effective at teaching knowledge and skills.

Perhaps it has become increasingly effective at assessing competencies.

But there remains a gap.

A wisdom gap.

The gap between knowing and understanding.

The gap between competence and excellence.

The gap between information and judgment.

The future of veterinary education may depend upon how successfully we address that gap.

Looking Ahead

Artificial intelligence may retrieve information.

Competency frameworks may measure performance.

Examinations may assess knowledge.

But judgment remains profoundly human.

It develops through experience.

Reflection. Mentorship. Mistakes. Humility. Time.

In many ways, judgment represents the ultimate educational challenge.

Because it cannot simply be taught.

It must be cultivated.

And perhaps that is the central mission of veterinary education.

Not merely producing veterinarians who know.

But producing veterinarians who know what to do when knowledge alone is not enough.

Coming Next

Part 8. Communication Is a Clinical Skill: The Most Important Subject We Rarely Teach Well.

Once we acknowledge that judgment is one of the most important skills in veterinary medicine, we must confront another uncomfortable reality:

A veterinarian can possess excellent knowledge, sound judgment, and exceptional technical skills

and still fail if they cannot communicate effectively.

Of all the essays in the series, this one may resonate most strongly with experienced practitioners.

Most veterinarians eventually realize that their reputation is not built primarily on what they know, but on the quality of the decisions they make when there is no obvious right answer.

That is the essence of judgment - and perhaps the hardest thing we ask veterinary schools to develop.

#bunyipsbooksbeyond