When Birds Give Up Flying (Part 1): Evolution’s Surprising Trade-Offs (#788)

Part 1
Why evolution sometimes favors losing one of nature’s greatest achievements
Flight is surely one of evolution’s most extraordinary achievements.
The ability to leave the ground, soar above predators, cross oceans, and migrate thousands of miles has allowed birds to colonize virtually every corner of our planet.
For most birds, flight is essential to survival. It provides access to food, opportunities to escape danger, and the freedom to move between habitats.
So why would any bird give it up?
After all, flight seems like an evolutionary advantage worth keeping.
Yet throughout evolutionary history, birds have repeatedly abandoned the skies.
Ostriches, emus, kiwis, penguins, and numerous island-dwelling species have independently lost the ability to fly.
And on the remote Galápagos Islands, one particularly remarkable bird has taken this evolutionary journey to an extraordinary extreme.
The flightless cormorant.
Its ancestors arrived by air.
Their descendants can no longer fly.
How did that happen?
Flying Is Expensive
Flight comes at a considerable biological cost.
Birds capable of sustained flight require powerful pectoral muscles, a specialized skeleton, highly efficient respiratory and cardiovascular systems, and feathers engineered for aerodynamic performance.
These adaptations demand energy to develop and maintain.
For a bird that must fly to escape predators, migrate, or locate food, the investment is worthwhile.
But imagine a flying bird arriving on a remote island where food is abundant, terrestrial predators are absent, and there is little reason to travel elsewhere.
Under these circumstances, the evolutionary advantages of flight may diminish.
Individuals that devote fewer resources to maintaining the machinery of flight may be just as successful, or even more successful, than their flying relatives.
Over many generations, natural selection may favor larger bodies, smaller wings, and reduced flight muscles.
Alternatively, the absence of selection to maintain flight may allow changes that impair flying ability to accumulate.
Eventually, the ability to fly may disappear altogether.
This is not evolution running backwards.
It is evolution responding to a different set of circumstances.
The Body Changes Before the Feathers
A fascinating study published in the journal Evolution in February 2025 provides new insight into how this transformation occurs.
Researchers led by Evan Saitta at Chicago's Field Museum examined the anatomy and feathers of 30 species of flightless birds and their flying relatives.
Their findings revealed something surprising:
When birds lose the ability to fly, their bodies change faster than their feathers.
Wing proportions, tail dimensions, skeletal structures, and body mass may change relatively early in the evolutionary process.
Yet the feathers can retain characteristics associated with flight long after flying itself has disappeared.
Why?
Part of the explanation involves the remarkable complexity of feathers.
Feathers are intricate biological structures produced through highly coordinated developmental processes.
Their architecture reflects millions of years of evolutionary history.
Changing these developmental processes is not necessarily straightforward.
The researchers found evidence that some feather characteristics disappear in approximately the reverse order in which they originally evolved.
Relatively recent adaptations, such as the asymmetry of flight feathers, may disappear sooner than more fundamental structural features.
In contrast, changes in skeletal proportions and body mass can occur comparatively early.
The result is an intriguing evolutionary mismatch.
A bird may possess a body that is no longer capable of flight while retaining feathers that still resemble those of its flying ancestors.
Evolution, it seems, does not discard every unnecessary feature at once.
Different Birds, Different Solutions
Flightlessness has evolved repeatedly, but not always for the same reasons.
Consider the ostrich.
The world's largest living bird has exchanged aerial mobility for powerful legs and exceptional running speed.
Its wings are no longer capable of lifting its enormous body into the air, but they remain useful for display, balance, and maneuvering.
Its feathers have also undergone remarkable changes.
Unlike the tightly structured flight feathers of most flying birds, ostrich feathers are relatively loose and soft.
The penguin represents a very different evolutionary solution.
Rather than abandoning its wings, the penguin has transformed them into highly specialized flippers.
Penguins cannot fly through the air, but they effectively fly underwater, using their modified forelimbs to propel themselves through the ocean.
Then there is the kiwi.
This extraordinary New Zealand bird has tiny, almost invisible wings and has adapted to a largely nocturnal existence, relying on its highly developed senses to locate food on the forest floor.
And there are the steamer ducks of southern South America, including the flightless Fuegian steamer duck.
These birds are particularly interesting because their loss of flight is comparatively recent.
Their feathers retain many of the characteristics of their flying relatives.
Together, these examples demonstrate that flightlessness is not a single evolutionary pathway.
It is an outcome that has arisen repeatedly under different ecological circumstances.
The Extraordinary Flightless Cormorant
Perhaps no bird illustrates the evolutionary abandonment of flight more dramatically than the flightless cormorant (Nannopterum harrisi) of the Galápagos Islands.
Among approximately 40 living species of cormorants, it is the only one that cannot fly.
It inhabits the rocky coastlines of Fernandina and Isabela islands, where it feeds in the productive waters of the eastern Pacific Ocean.
At first glance, it looks much like other cormorants.
It has a long neck, a streamlined body, powerful webbed feet, and the familiar habit of spreading its wings after emerging from the water.
But look more closely.
Its wings are extraordinarily small.
Its flight muscles are greatly reduced, and the keel of its sternum, which provides attachment for the powerful flight muscles of flying birds, is similarly diminished.
These are not minor anatomical differences.
They represent a profound transformation of the machinery of flight.
Yet the flightless cormorant is anything but poorly adapted.
It is an accomplished underwater hunter, using its powerful pelvic limbs to propel itself in pursuit of fish and other marine prey.
Unlike penguins, which use their wings for underwater propulsion, the flightless cormorant relies primarily on its feet.
Its wings are no longer essential for locomotion in either air or water.
The bird has effectively abandoned one of the defining characteristics of its flying ancestors.
And it has done so remarkably recently in evolutionary terms.
Genetic evidence suggests that the flightless cormorant shared a common ancestor with its closest flying relatives approximately two million years ago.
That is a relatively short period in which to transform a flying seabird into one with wings incapable of supporting flight.
Which raises a fascinating question.
How does evolution actually accomplish such a dramatic anatomical transformation?
We will return to that question in Part 2: When Losing Flight Becomes an Advantage.
It is tempting to assume that flightless birds simply lost the ability to fly because they no longer needed it.
But the story may be more interesting.
In some circumstances, losing flight may provide a positive evolutionary advantage.
The flightless cormorant offers a particularly intriguing example.
A larger body may permit greater oxygen storage, potentially allowing longer dives.
Reduced wings may decrease buoyancy and the energetic costs associated with underwater foraging.
These possibilities suggest that flightlessness may not merely result from the absence of predators or the relaxation of natural selection.
It may sometimes be actively favored.
In other words, the flightless cormorant may not simply have lost the ability to fly.
It may have become better adapted to a life in which flying was no longer particularly useful.
That distinction is important.
Evolution does not necessarily favor organisms that can do the greatest number of things.
It favors organisms whose characteristics contribute to reproductive success in their particular environment.
Sometimes specialization involves acquiring new abilities.
Sometimes it involves losing old ones.
The Price of Flightlessness
There is, however, a serious disadvantage to becoming flightless.
An adaptation that works beautifully in one environment may become disastrous when that environment changes.
Many flightless birds evolved on islands where terrestrial predators were absent or uncommon.
Then humans arrived.
With them came rats, cats, dogs, pigs, and other introduced animals.
Birds that had evolved without the need to escape by flying suddenly encountered predators against which they had few defenses.
The dodo of Mauritius is perhaps the most famous example.
The giant moa of New Zealand and numerous flightless rails suffered similar fates.
Their evolutionary specialization had become a liability.
The flightless cormorant faces its own challenges.
Its entire population occupies a remarkably restricted geographical range.
Changes in ocean temperatures, marine productivity, disease exposure, or the arrival of introduced predators could have serious consequences.
Events such as El Niño can dramatically alter the availability of marine food resources.
And unlike its flying relatives, the flightless cormorant cannot simply take to the skies in search of better conditions.
Its evolutionary success is intimately tied to the environment in which it evolved.
This illustrates one of the most important principles of evolutionary biology.
Evolution does not anticipate the future.
Evolution favors characteristics that confer advantages under existing conditions.
What Can Flightless Birds Tell Us About Dinosaurs?
The 2025 Field Museum study also has implications extending far beyond living birds.
Birds are the surviving descendants of theropod dinosaurs, and many extinct dinosaurs possessed feathers.
But feathers do not necessarily indicate an ability to fly.
If skeletal proportions change before feathers lose their aerodynamic characteristics, a fossil bird or feathered dinosaur might retain apparently flight-adapted feathers despite having already become flightless.
This complicates efforts to reconstruct the locomotor abilities of extinct animals.
A fossil's feathers may tell us something about its evolutionary ancestry without necessarily revealing whether the animal could actually fly.
The researchers suggest that skeletal proportions, body mass, and relative wing length may provide important clues when evaluating flight capability in extinct species.
Once again, evolutionary history matters.
Anatomical structures may persist long after their original functions have disappeared.
Evolution Is Not a Ladder
We often imagine evolution as a progression toward greater complexity, sophistication, or capability.
But evolution has no predetermined destination.
There is no universal hierarchy in which flying birds are more evolved than flightless birds.
The ostrich is no less evolved than an eagle.
The penguin is no less successful because it cannot soar above the ocean.
And the flightless cormorant is not an evolutionary failure because its wings can no longer lift it from the water.
Each represents a different solution to the challenges of survival and reproduction.
The important question is not why these birds failed to retain flight.
It is why flight ceased to be worth maintaining.
The Freedom Not to Fly
There is something wonderfully paradoxical about a bird that cannot fly.
We tend to regard flight as the ultimate expression of freedom.
Yet, for some birds, evolutionary success has depended upon abandoning it.
The flightless cormorant is perhaps the most remarkable example.
Its ancestors crossed the ocean on functional wings, eventually reaching the remote volcanic islands of the Galápagos.
Their descendants have become so specialized for a marine existence that those wings are now little more than reminders of an aerial past.
They still spread them to dry and preen their feathers, looking rather like ordinary cormorants whose wings have somehow shrunk in the wash.
But they have not forgotten how to fly.
Their anatomy has evolved to the point where flight is no longer possible.
And that raises an even more intriguing question.
What changes within the developing embryo allow a bird to grow wings that are too small to fly?
How do genes that have helped construct functional wings for millions of years become associated with such dramatically reduced structures?
The answer involves genetics, embryonic development, and some extraordinarily small cellular structures that play a surprisingly important role in determining the size and shape of the skeleton.
That is where our story goes next.
Because the most fascinating thing about the flightless cormorant may not be that it lost the ability to fly, but how evolution changed the developmental machinery that once made flight possible.

Coming in Part 2
The Bird That Lost Its Wings: The Genetics of Flightlessness.
How genetic changes affecting cellular signaling and skeletal development helped transform the Galápagos cormorant.
References
Saitta, E. T., Carden, L., Mitchell, J. S., & Makovicky, P. J. (2025). Feather evolution following flight loss in crown group birds: Relaxed selection and developmental constraints. Evolution. https://doi.org/10.1093/evolut/qpaf020
Burga, A., et al. (2017). A genetic signature of the evolution of loss of flight in the Galapagos cormorant. Science, 356, eaal3345. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aal3345



Comments