Doing the Right Thing: The Courage of Shared Governance (#789)

When institutional loyalty conflicts with professional duty, who decides what is right?
There is a fundamental question at the heart of every ethical dilemma:
Should we do what is right because it produces the best outcome.
Or should we do what is right simply because it is right?
Philosophers have debated this question for centuries.
University administrators, faculty members, and those entrusted with institutional governance confront versions of it regularly, whether they recognize it or not.
The distinction is particularly relevant when universities accept substantial philanthropic gifts, make consequential institutional decisions, and ask their faculty representatives to approve arrangements that may already have been substantially negotiated.
It is also relevant to a question that has emerged repeatedly during the discussion surrounding the renaming of the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine:
Is following the prescribed procedure sufficient to satisfy the principles of shared governance?
I believe the answer is no.
Consequences Versus Principles
Two schools of moral philosophy offer different ways of approaching ethical decisions.
Consequentialism and Deontology.
Consequentialism judges the morality of an action primarily by its outcomes.
An action is justified when its consequences produce more good than harm.
A consequentialist might argue that withholding information, limiting consultation, or accelerating a decision can be justified if doing so secures an overwhelmingly beneficial outcome.
A substantial philanthropic donation, for example.
Deontology, by contrast, emphasizes moral duties and principles.
Certain obligations, such as honesty, fairness, and respect for others, should be honored independently of whether doing so produces the most convenient result.
A deontologist might argue that transparency and meaningful consultation are obligations that cannot simply be discarded because they complicate negotiations or threaten an attractive opportunity.
Neither philosophical tradition is without complexity.
Consequentialists may value transparency because it promotes long-term trust.
Deontologists may recognize competing duties and exceptional circumstances.
Nevertheless, the distinction illuminates an important institutional dilemma.
What happens when the perceived benefits of a decision begin to overshadow the principles by which that decision should be made?
The Philanthropic Dilemma
Consider a hypothetical university offered a transformational donation.
The gift promises new facilities, expanded programs, enhanced prestige, and opportunities that might otherwise remain beyond reach.
But the gift also comes with conditions.
There are deadlines. Naming commitments. Advisory arrangements. Recognition requirements. Perhaps even expectations about the timing of institutional decisions.
University leaders understandably want to secure the donation.
From a consequentialist perspective, they might reason that the benefits justify an accelerated approval process, restricted disclosure, or limited faculty consultation.
After all, losing the donation could be disastrous.
But a different question deserves equal consideration.
Does the prospect of losing a gift justify compromising the principles of shared governance?
The answer cannot depend exclusively on the size of the gift.
A public university is not simply a business negotiating a commercial transaction.
A public university is an institution with educational responsibilities, public obligations, academic traditions, and established mechanisms for shared decision-making.
Its governance principles are not merely administrative inconveniences to be managed when time permits.
They are part of what makes it a university.
The Faculty Executive Committee: Representative or Administrator?
This distinction becomes especially important when considering the role of a Faculty Executive Committee (FEC).
An FEC exists to represent faculty interests within an institution's governance structure.
An FEC should serve as a bridge between faculty and administration, not simply as an extension of administrative leadership.
That responsibility involves more than attending meetings, receiving documents, and casting votes.
That responsibility requires independent judgment.
That responsibility requires asking difficult questions.
And, where appropriate, that responsibility requires consultation with the faculty whose interests the committee represents.
There is an important distinction between procedural governance and substantive governance.
Procedural governance asks:
Was the appropriate committee consulted?
Was the necessary vote taken?
Were the prescribed approvals obtained?
Substantive governance asks something more demanding:
Was sufficient information available?
Was there adequate time for deliberation?
Were affected stakeholders meaningfully consulted?
Could stakeholder contributions have influenced the decision?
Both procedural governance and substantive governance matter.
A university may satisfy formal procedural requirements while still falling short of the broader ideals of shared governance.
Equally, a representative committee must sometimes preserve confidentiality, and not every institutional decision requires a vote of the entire faculty.
But confidentiality should serve a legitimate institutional purpose.
Confidentiality should not become a convenient substitute for consultation.
And representation should never be confused with merely being informed.
The Weill Gift and the Question of Timing
These questions are central to the continuing examination of the Weill gift to the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine.
The $120 million donation represents an extraordinary philanthropic commitment.
Its potential benefits deserve recognition.
But the agreement was not simply an unconditional transfer of money.
The agreement involved institutional naming, deadlines, recognition obligations, and an advisory arrangement.
These were consequential commitments with implications extending beyond the name displayed on a building or letterhead.
Yet the renaming was presented to faculty governance bodies as a simple name change.
The chronology raises a particularly important concern.
Presidential approval of the naming commitment was communicated on August 18, 2025, approximately three months before the FEC's November consideration.
That sequence raises questions about the opportunity for meaningful faculty influence before institutional commitments were substantially established.
The short period reportedly devoted to FEC deliberation, the use of confidentiality, and the donor-imposed timetable all deserve examination.
None of these facts, individually, establishes that a governance rule was violated.
Together, however, they raise a legitimate question:
Was faculty consultation through the FEC an opportunity to influence the decision, or primarily an opportunity to endorse a decision already made?
The distinction matters enormously.
The Wallabies and the Source of Motivation
An apparently unrelated observation from Australian rugby offers a useful perspective.
Wallabies (the Australian rugby team name) scrum coach John Ulugia recently acknowledged that players must accept criticism when they perform poorly.
But he emphasized that their motivation to improve must come from within, rather than from external pressure.
It is a valuable lesson in professional responsibility.
A good rugby player does not strive for excellence simply because spectators criticize poor performance.
The motivation comes from an internal commitment to standards, teammates, and the integrity of the game.
The same principle should apply to university governance.
Faculty representatives should not require public criticism, external scrutiny, or the threat of an investigation before asking whether their decisions meet the standards of the institution they serve.
Their commitment to those standards should be intrinsic.
The strongest defense of shared governance is not pressure from those who question its effectiveness.
It is the conviction of those entrusted with practicing it.
This does not mean that every faculty representative must agree with every criticism.
It means that questions deserve substantive answers, and that institutional accountability should not depend on whether someone has the persistence to demand them.
Loyalty to an Institution Is Not Loyalty to Its Administration
There is another distinction worth emphasizing.
Faculty representatives may feel a strong obligation to support their dean, protect the reputation of their school, and preserve opportunities for institutional advancement.
These are understandable sentiments.
But loyalty to an institution is not necessarily the same as loyalty to its current administration.
Indeed, the two may occasionally conflict.
An administrator may believe that accepting a particular agreement is in the university's best interests.
A faculty representative may believe that the agreement requires broader consultation before approval.
Both may be acting in good faith.
The disagreement is not necessarily between those who support the university and those who oppose it.
It may instead reflect different understandings of what responsible institutional stewardship requires.
A healthy university should be capable of accommodating those differences.
Its governance system should encourage informed disagreement rather than regard dissent as disloyalty.
When the Ends Begin to Justify the Means
One of the most troubling arguments in debates over large philanthropic gifts is also one of the simplest:
We might have lost the gift.
Perhaps.
That possibility deserves serious consideration.
But it cannot be the end of the discussion.
If the risk of losing a donation becomes sufficient justification for restricting consultation, accelerating deliberation, or accepting institutional commitments without meaningful scrutiny, then the donor's timetable may effectively displace the university's governance timetable.
That creates an uncomfortable precedent.
What happens when the next donation is even larger?
Or when its conditions are more demanding?
At what point does the university decide that its governance principles are too important to be negotiated away?
The appropriate response is not to reject philanthropy.
The appropriate response is to ensure that philanthropy operates within the university's established values and responsibilities.
A university should be capable of saying to a prospective donor:
We welcome your generosity.
We value your commitment.
But we also have obligations to our faculty, students, staff, and the public.
Those obligations require meaningful consultation before we make consequential institutional commitments.
That is not ingratitude.
It is institutional integrity.
The Courage to Ask Questions
In November 2026, the UC Davis Academic Senate Representative Assembly voted 53–12, with three abstentions, in favor of initiating an inquiry into the shared governance aspects of the Weill gift.
That vote did not establish wrongdoing.
Nor should it be interpreted as a rejection of the donation or an accusation against individual faculty representatives.
It recognized that legitimate questions deserve independent examination.
The inquiry offers an opportunity to distinguish formal procedural compliance from the broader responsibilities of meaningful shared governance.
It should examine what information was available, when decisions were made, who was consulted, how much time was provided, and whether faculty input could realistically have changed the outcome.
It should also distinguish the responsibilities of the Faculty Executive Committee, the school administration, campus leadership, and the Office of the President.
The objective should be institutional learning, not personal blame.
That is how a university strengthens its governance rather than merely defends its past decisions.
Doing Right When Nobody Is Watching
The philosophical distinction between consequentialism and deontology brings us back to a fundamental question.
Is a governance process good because it produces a desirable outcome?
Or is it good because it respects the principles that make the outcome legitimate?
In practice, responsible governance must consider both consequences and duties.
A university cannot ignore the benefits of a major donation.
But neither should it treat transparency, independent judgment, and meaningful consultation as optional costs of doing business.
The Wallabies coach's observation adds another dimension.
Excellence is most durable when it comes from within.
So is integrity.
Faculty representatives should not need an external investigation to remind them of their responsibility to those they represent.
Administrators should not need public criticism to recognize the value of consultation.
And universities should not need controversy to reaffirm the principles they publicly celebrate.
Shared governance is not demonstrated by the existence of committees, the completion of approval forms, or the recording of votes.
It is demonstrated by the quality, independence, and integrity of the deliberations that precede institutional decisions.
The true test of shared governance comes not when everyone agrees, but when important interests compete, deadlines loom, and the temptation to take shortcuts becomes strongest.
That is precisely when principles matter most.
And that is precisely when doing the right thing must be more than a calculation of what can be gained.
The measure of institutional integrity is not simply whether a university achieves a desirable outcome, but whether it remains faithful to its principles in achieving it.



Comments