The Modern Vet School (Part 1): Accreditation After the AVMA? (#791)

The future of veterinary education is being reorganized.
But who gets to decide what replaces the existing system?
For decades, the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) has occupied an extraordinarily influential position in veterinary education.
Through its Council on Education (COE), the AVMA has helped determine which veterinary schools meet accreditation standards, what resources those schools must provide, and whether their graduates are considered adequately prepared to enter the profession.
Most veterinarians have probably given this arrangement little thought.
Accreditation happens somewhere in the background.
Veterinary schools prepare for site visits.
Committees review documents.
Standards are assessed.
Reports are issued.
And the profession continues.
But something fundamental is changing.
In October 2026, the United States Department of Education finalized regulations intended to increase the independence of accrediting agencies from professional and trade associations.
The AVMA has responded by announcing plans to establish a separate nonprofit accrediting organization.
The Council on Education is expected to continue operating during the transition, while arrangements for a successor are developed.
According to reporting by Lisa Wogan in the Veterinary Information Network (VIN), the restructuring is already underway.
The question is no longer whether veterinary accreditation will change.
The question is who will control the organization that replaces the existing arrangement.
The AVMA's unusual position
The AVMA is a professional membership organization.
It represents veterinarians, advocates for professional interests, provides member services, and participates in public policy discussions.
Those are legitimate and important functions.
But accreditation is different.
Accreditation exists to protect educational quality, establish expectations for professional competence, and provide assurance to students, licensing authorities, and the public.
The interests of a professional association and an accrediting agency may overlap considerably.
They are not necessarily identical.
Consider the question of veterinary workforce supply.
A professional association may be concerned about whether there are too many or too few veterinarians entering the workforce.
An accrediting agency should be concerned primarily with whether veterinary schools are capable of providing an adequate education to the students they admit.
These considerations may influence one another, but they should not be confused.
The potential for conflicting priorities is one reason independence matters.
A controversy that did not begin in 2026
The VIN investigation provides useful historical context.
Concerns about the relationship between the AVMA and its accrediting council have been raised for years.
Questions about transparency, conflicts of interest, and the influence of professional interests on accreditation decisions were prominent during federal reviews of the COE more than a decade ago.
The council subsequently introduced reforms and retained federal recognition.
These historical concerns do not establish that accreditation decisions were improper.
They do demonstrate that the relationship between professional representation and educational oversight has long been contested.
The new federal regulations have made that relationship a practical organizational problem rather than merely a philosophical debate.
The AVMA now faces the task of establishing an accrediting organization capable of satisfying new federal requirements.
But establishing a separate organization raises questions that deserve answers before its structure becomes entrenched.
Who appoints the board?
This may be the most important question of all.
A new accrediting organization will presumably require a governing board, executive leadership, committees, administrative staff, and procedures for establishing and enforcing accreditation standards.
Who will appoint those individuals?
Will the AVMA retain any authority over board appointments?
Will the Association of American Veterinary Medical Colleges (AAVMC) have a formal role?
Will practicing veterinarians be represented?
Will veterinary faculty members participate independently of their institutions' administrations?
Will students and members of the public have a voice?
And who will have the authority to remove board members or change the organization's governing documents?
These are not minor administrative details.
They determine where power resides.
A nonprofit corporation can be legally separate from its founding organization while remaining strongly influenced by the people and institutions responsible for creating it.
That does not mean the proposed AVMA successor will lack independence.
It means independence must be demonstrated through its actual governance arrangements.
A change of corporate name does not necessarily mean a change in who makes the decisions.
Who will pay for independence?
There is another complication:
Money.
In her November 2026 commentary, Navigating Change Together, AAVMC Chief Executive Officer Dr. Emma Read reports that the AVMA has been paying approximately half the annual costs of accreditation.
That subsidy has reduced the financial burden on veterinary schools.
But a genuinely separate accrediting agency will require its own financial arrangements.
Independent staff, administrative systems, legal services, offices, and governance structures cost money.
Who will pay?
If the AVMA's financial contribution ends, will veterinary schools face substantially higher accreditation fees?
Will those costs be incorporated into tuition?
Will students ultimately pay more for the same accreditation services?
Or will the new organization develop alternative sources of revenue?
There is an additional question.
If an accrediting organization depends heavily on fees paid by the institutions it evaluates, how does it ensure that financial dependence does not compromise its judgment?
This is not an argument against accreditation fees.
Such fees are common and necessary.
It is an argument for transparency.
The profession should know how the new organization will be funded, who will control its budget, and what safeguards will protect its independence.
Who determines what constitutes a competent veterinarian?
The most consequential issue may not be organizational structure or financing.
It may be educational philosophy.
Accreditation influences the fundamental design of veterinary education.
It helps determine faculty requirements, clinical training expectations, institutional resources, educational outcomes, and methods of assessing student competence.
These requirements have profound consequences.
They influence the cost of veterinary education, the feasibility of establishing new schools, and the ability of existing schools to experiment with different educational models.
Veterinary education is already confronting major questions:
Should every veterinary degree require four years of professional education?
Can competency-based education provide a more effective measure of readiness to practice?
What role should distributive clinical education play?
How should artificial intelligence, simulation, and new technologies be incorporated into veterinary training?
Should accreditation focus more heavily on demonstrable clinical competence and less on institutional infrastructure?
And perhaps most importantly, should veterinary education prepare graduates simply to be job-ready, or should it prepare them to be profession-ready?
These questions should not be answered exclusively by administrators.
They require meaningful participation from veterinary educators, practicing veterinarians, students, professional organizations, and the public.
The problem of expertise
The new federal regulations introduce another interesting complication.
They restrict the ability of individuals employed by accredited institutions to vote on the adoption or revision of accreditation standards.
The intention is understandable.
An individual employed by an institution being evaluated should not be in a position to establish standards that directly benefit that institution.
But veterinary education is a specialized field.
Much of the expertise required to establish meaningful educational standards resides within veterinary schools themselves.
Faculty members understand curriculum design, clinical teaching, educational assessment, and the practical challenges of preparing students for professional practice.
If their voting authority is restricted, how will that expertise be incorporated?
Will the new organization rely more heavily on external representatives?
Who will select them?
And how will it ensure that the resulting standards reflect sound educational judgment rather than political, commercial, or institutional interests?
There is a distinction between preventing conflicts of interest and excluding relevant expertise.
A successful accreditation system must accomplish the first without sacrificing the second.
A profession-wide responsibility
The AVMA and AAVMC have considerable experience in veterinary education.
Their participation in developing a new accreditation system is both understandable and necessary.
But participation should not be confused with exclusive ownership.
The decisions now being contemplated will affect veterinary education for decades.
They will influence the establishment of new schools, the education of future veterinarians, the financial obligations of students, and the public's confidence in professional competence.
These are matters of broad professional importance.
They deserve broad professional discussion.
In particular, the proposed governance arrangements for the new accrediting agency should be available for examination before they are finalized.
The profession should be able to evaluate the proposed board structure, appointment processes, financial arrangements, conflict-of-interest safeguards, and procedures for revising accreditation standards.
And it should have meaningful opportunities to influence those arrangements.
Consultation after decisions have effectively been made is not the same as shared governance.
Who owns accreditation?
The AVMA deserves recognition for its longstanding investment in veterinary accreditation.
Its financial and organizational contributions have helped sustain a system that has played an important role in maintaining educational standards.
But the establishment of a new accrediting agency offers an opportunity to examine whether the existing system can be improved.
It would be unfortunate if that opportunity resulted in little more than the transfer of familiar structures into a newly incorporated organization.
Accreditation does not exist to serve the AVMA.
Nor does accreditation exist to serve veterinary school administrators, professional associations, or the institutions being accredited.
Accreditation exists to protect educational quality, professional competence, animal welfare, and public confidence.
Those responsibilities transcend organizational interests.
The real question is not who will own the new accrediting agency.
It is whether the new agency will be governed in a way that makes ownership irrelevant to its independent judgment.
That is the standard against which the new arrangements should be judged.
And it is a conversation the entire veterinary profession should participate in.
Part 2 of this two part series will examine the new federal accreditation rules and ask whether organizational separation will actually deliver the independence, accountability, and educational quality that the reforms promise.
Principal Sources for Part 1
AVMA to create new accrediting entity. VIN News November 9, 2026. https://publicnews.vin.com/default.aspx?Id=13587612&catId=610&pid=210&utm
Navigating Change Together. AAVMC November 2026. https://www.aavmc.org/news/navigating-change-together/?utm
What We Know and What We Don’t After Publication of the AIM Final Accreditation Rules. CHEA November 17, 2026. https://www.chea.org/what-we-know-what-we-dont-aim-final?utm



Comments