top of page

The Bird That Lost Its Wings (Part 2): The Genetics of Flightlessness (#790)

Rick LeCouteur
3 hours ago
9 min read
How tiny changes in the machinery of skeletal development helped transform the Galápagos cormorant
How tiny changes in the machinery of skeletal development helped transform the Galápagos cormorant

In Part 1, When Birds Give Up Flying: Evolution's Surprising Trade-Offs, we explored one of evolution's most intriguing paradoxes.


Why would a bird abandon the ability to fly?


We discovered that flight is expensive, that evolution does not necessarily favor retaining abilities that are no longer useful, and that flightlessness has evolved independently in numerous bird lineages.


We also met one of nature's most extraordinary examples of this phenomenon.


The flightless cormorant of the Galápagos Islands.


Its ancestors could fly.


Its descendants cannot.


But that raises an even more fascinating question:


How does evolution turn a flying bird into a flightless one?


How does a bird that inherits the genetic instructions for producing wings end up with wings so small that they can no longer support flight?


The answer involves genetics, embryonic development, cartilage, and some extraordinarily small structures found on the surfaces of cells.


And it provides a remarkable connection between evolutionary biology and human medicine.


A Remarkable Natural Experiment


The flightless cormorant (Nannopterum harrisi) is found exclusively along the coastlines of Fernandina and Isabela islands in the Galápagos archipelago.


Among approximately 40 living species of cormorants, it is the only one incapable of flight.


Its wings are dramatically reduced, its flight muscles are poorly developed, and the keel of its sternum, which normally provides attachment for powerful flight muscles, is greatly diminished.


Yet it remains an accomplished underwater hunter.


It is also a comparatively recent evolutionary arrival.


Genetic evidence suggests that the flightless cormorant shared a common ancestor with its closest flying relatives approximately two million years ago.


In evolutionary terms, that is remarkably recent.


Somewhere along the way, the developmental processes responsible for constructing a flying bird's wings were altered.


But how?


In 2017, a team led by Alejandro Burga published a fascinating paper in Science entitled A Genetic Signature of the Evolution of Loss of Flight in the Galapagos Cormorant.


Rather than simply examining the bird's anatomy, the researchers investigated its genome.


They wanted to discover whether identifiable genetic changes could help explain how flightlessness evolved.


What they found was extraordinary.


Comparing the Genetic Blueprints


The researchers sequenced the genomes of four cormorant species.


Three were capable of flight: the double-crested cormorant, the neotropical cormorant, and the pelagic cormorant.


The fourth was the flightless Galápagos cormorant.


By comparing their genetic sequences, the investigators could search for differences unique to the flightless species.


They identified thousands of genetic variants.


Most were unlikely to have major biological consequences.


But some occurred in genes known to influence skeletal growth and development.


And among these were several genes associated with an unexpected cellular structure:


The primary cilium.


The Tiny Cellular Antenna


When we think of cilia, we usually imagine microscopic hairlike structures that move fluid or mucus across the surfaces of cells.


The motile cilia lining the respiratory tract are a familiar example.


But many vertebrate cells also possess a different structure called a primary cilium.


Unlike motile cilia, primary cilia generally do not beat back and forth.


Instead, they function as sensory and signaling centers.


They help cells receive and interpret molecular messages from their surroundings.


These signals are particularly important during embryonic development, when cells must coordinate their growth, differentiation, and organization into tissues and organs.


One of the most important signaling systems involving primary cilia is the Hedgehog pathway.


Despite its rather whimsical name, Hedgehog signaling plays a fundamental role in vertebrate development.


It helps regulate the growth and patterning of limbs, the nervous system, and numerous other structures.


Within developing bones, a related signaling molecule called Indian Hedgehog helps coordinate the proliferation and maturation of cartilage cells.


These cartilage cells, or chondrocytes, are essential to the formation and elongation of many bones.


Disrupt the signaling system, and skeletal growth may be altered.


And this is where the flightless cormorant becomes particularly interesting.


A Surprising Connection to Human Disease


The researchers discovered that the flightless cormorant carried potentially function-altering variants in several genes involved in primary cilium formation and function.


These included OFD1, EVC, IFT122, and WDR34.


Why was this significant?


Because mutations affecting some of these same genes are associated with human developmental disorders known as ciliopathies.


Certain skeletal ciliopathies produce shortened limbs, abnormal bone development, and abnormalities of the rib cage.


The parallels with the flightless cormorant were striking.


Its wings are extraordinarily short, and its sternum is markedly reduced.


Could changes in ciliary signaling have contributed to the evolutionary reduction of these structures?


The researchers believed they might.


Importantly, this does not mean that the flightless cormorant suffers from a human-like genetic disease.


A genetic change that causes serious developmental problems in one species may have different consequences in another, depending on its severity, genetic background, and evolutionary context.


The same biological pathways can contribute to disease in one setting and evolutionary adaptation in another.


That is one of the most fascinating aspects of comparative biology.


Four Missing Amino Acids


Among the many genetic differences identified, one was particularly intriguing.

It involved a gene called CUX1.


CUX1 encodes a transcription factor, a protein that helps regulate the activity of other genes.


Transcription factors play crucial roles in development because they help determine which genes are switched on or off, when they are expressed, and to what extent.


The researchers discovered that the flightless cormorant possesses a deletion affecting just four amino acids in the CUX1 protein.


Four amino acids!


In a protein whose corresponding sequence is remarkably conserved across birds and mammals.


The deletion was especially interesting because CUX1 is involved in processes influencing limb development and cartilage formation.


Could such a small alteration contribute to such a dramatic anatomical transformation?


To investigate, the researchers performed experiments using cultured cells capable of differentiating into cartilage-producing cells.


They compared the effects of the ancestral form of CUX1 with the altered form found in the flightless cormorant.


The results were revealing.


The cormorant version was less effective at activating certain genes associated with ciliary function.


It was also less effective at promoting aspects of cartilage-cell differentiation.


In other words, a deletion involving just four amino acids could measurably alter developmental processes associated with skeletal growth.


That does not prove that this deletion alone caused the cormorant's wings to shrink.


Indeed, the evidence suggests that multiple genetic changes contributed to the transformation.


But it provides a compelling example of how relatively small genetic alterations can influence the construction of an entire anatomical structure.


Putting a Cormorant Mutation Into a Worm


The researchers went even further.


They identified a potentially important variant in another gene, IFT122, which is involved in the transport of molecular components within cilia.


Rather than relying entirely on computational predictions, they tested the functional consequences of this variant experimentally.


Using CRISPR gene editing, they introduced the corresponding amino acid substitution into the equivalent gene of the microscopic roundworm Caenorhabditis elegans.


Why a worm?


Because the fundamental machinery of ciliary function is remarkably conserved across evolution.


Although worms and birds are separated by hundreds of millions of years of evolutionary history, they share many cellular mechanisms.


The genetically modified worms exhibited altered behavior associated with ciliary sensory function.


This provided experimental evidence that the cormorant-associated genetic variant could affect the function of a ciliary protein.


It did not demonstrate that the mutation directly caused wing reduction in birds.


But it strengthened the case that the researchers had identified biologically meaningful genetic changes rather than merely incidental differences between species.


The experiment also illustrated a remarkable principle:


To understand the evolution of a bird's wings, scientists could learn something important from a microscopic worm.


Did the Wings Simply Stop Growing?


One particularly intriguing possibility involves the timing of development.


The flightless cormorant's wings are not entirely absent.


They contain the familiar skeletal elements of a bird's forelimb, but these structures are greatly reduced.


The radius and ulna, for example, are disproportionately short relative to the humerus.


This raises the possibility that the developmental processes responsible for wing growth have been modified rather than eliminated.


Biologists use the term heterochrony to describe evolutionary changes in the timing or rate of developmental events.


One form of heterochrony is paedomorphosis, in which an adult organism retains characteristics resembling those of a juvenile ancestor.


The flightless cormorant may provide an example.


Its wings and pectoral skeleton retain certain juvenile-like proportions into adulthood.


The researchers proposed that changes in ciliary and Hedgehog signaling could help explain this developmental pattern by altering the proliferation and maturation of cartilage cells.


The result would be reduced growth of the developing wing and associated skeletal structures.


This is a fascinating possibility.


The cormorant may not have evolved an entirely new developmental program for producing small wings.


Instead, evolution may have modified the timing and extent of growth within an existing developmental program.


A relatively modest change in developmental regulation can sometimes produce a remarkable change in adult anatomy.


Did Natural Selection Favor Smaller Wings?


There is another important question.


Were these genetic changes simply tolerated because flight was no longer necessary?


Or did they provide a positive advantage?


Traditionally, the loss of flight in island birds has often been explained by relaxed natural selection.


Without terrestrial predators, birds no longer experience the same evolutionary pressure to maintain the ability to fly.


Mutations that reduce flight performance may therefore accumulate without imposing a substantial disadvantage.


But the flightless cormorant may tell a more complicated story.


Smaller wings may reduce buoyancy during diving, while a larger body may provide greater oxygen-storage capacity.


These characteristics could improve underwater foraging performance.


The researchers therefore investigated whether some of the genes associated with flightlessness showed evidence of positive natural selection.


They found suggestive evidence in several genes, with a statistically significant signal for GLI2, another gene involved in Hedgehog signaling.


This does not establish that natural selection directly favored every anatomical change associated with flightlessness.


But it supports the possibility that the cormorant's transformation involved more than the passive accumulation of mutations.


Some changes may have been actively favored because they improved performance in the bird's marine environment.


The distinction is subtle but important.


The cormorant may not simply have lost flight because it no longer needed to fly.


Evolution may also have favored characteristics that made flying increasingly difficult while improving its ability to dive.


Evolution Works With What It Already Has


Perhaps the most important lesson from this research is that evolution does not require the invention of entirely new genes to produce dramatic anatomical changes.


Much of evolutionary change involves modifications to existing developmental pathways.


The genes responsible for building limbs are ancient.


Many of the signaling systems that regulate skeletal development are shared across vertebrates.


Yet alterations in how these systems function can produce an extraordinary diversity of anatomical forms.


The wings of an eagle, the flippers of a penguin, the forelimbs of a dog, and the arms of a human are all variations on a deeply conserved vertebrate developmental framework.

The flightless cormorant represents another variation.


Its wings are not the result of an entirely different genetic blueprint.


They are the product of modifications to developmental machinery inherited from flying ancestors.


And the same machinery has important roles in the development of our own skeletons.


What We Still Do Not Know


As compelling as the findings are, there are important limitations.


The researchers identified multiple genetic variants likely to influence ciliary function and skeletal development.


They demonstrated functional effects for selected variants in experimental systems.


But they did not recreate the flightless cormorant's anatomy by introducing these mutations into a flying bird.


Nor did they establish the precise evolutionary sequence in which the relevant mutations arose.


It remains uncertain which changes were essential, which were secondary, and how they interacted.


Other genes, including noncoding regulatory sequences, may also have contributed.


And the extent to which natural selection favored these changes remains incompletely understood.


The study therefore provides a persuasive genetic and developmental model for the evolution of flightlessness, rather than a complete demonstration of every causal step.


That distinction matters.


Good science is not simply about finding answers.


It is also about recognizing what remains to be discovered.


A Final Thought: Four Amino Acids and Two Million Years


Consider the remarkable evolutionary journey of the flightless cormorant.


Approximately two million years ago, its ancestors shared the ability to fly with other cormorants.


Today, their descendants possess wings that are incapable of lifting them into the air.


Between those two points lies a history of ecological change, natural selection, genetic variation, and altered embryonic development.


And among the genetic differences associated with that transformation is a deletion involving just four amino acids.


Four tiny components of a protein involved in regulating development.


Not the whole explanation, certainly.


But potentially an important part of it.


The story beautifully illustrates the relationship between evolution and embryology.


Evolution determines which genetic variants persist across generations.


Development translates those inherited instructions into the anatomy of the individual.


Together, they shape the extraordinary diversity of life.


The flightless cormorant has not forgotten how to fly.


Its developmental machinery has evolved to produce a bird for which flight is no longer possible.


And in understanding how that happened, we gain insights not only into the evolution of birds but also into the fundamental biological processes that construct the skeletons of all vertebrates, including ourselves.


Sometimes the most dramatic changes in evolution begin with remarkably small changes in the genetic instructions for building a body.


Reference

 

Burga, A., Wang, W., Ben-David, E., et al. (2017). A genetic signature of the evolution of loss of flight in the Galapagos cormorant. Science, 356(6341), eaal3345. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aal3345


Previously in this two part series


Part 1: When Birds Give Up Flying: Evolution's Surprising Trade-Offs


Why birds repeatedly abandon flight, how their bodies change before their feathers, and why losing an apparently valuable ability can sometimes be an evolutionary advantage.


Comments


©2026 by Rick LeCouteur. Created with Wix.com

bottom of page